I felt like I was holding my breath the whole time I was knitting this sweater.
I just knew it wasn’t going to fit.
I was on vacation when I started it, so didn’t do a gauge swatch or have my body form to try it on, so it was just a big guessing game.
Not to mention I opted to make the extra small, when I should have made the small, according to my measurements. YIKES.
It was wayyyyy too small; I just felt it in my bones.
I finished it just so I could get ‘er done and get started on my next sweater. And you know what?
I finished it/blocked it (by wetting and pinning into shape and allowing to dry)/tried it on/and…
IT FITS! Whew! YAY!
Here’s the scoop:
PATTERN: Shapely Boyfriend Cardigan by Stefanie Japel
YARN: 4 skeins of my superwash merino wool in Butterscotch (check back often for new colors, as they sell outttt fasssttt)
NEEDLES: US Size 8/5 mm (for the whole thing… I never switched to the small needles for the ribbing, like a goober. Wish I had.)
SIZE: X-Small (even though I should have made the Small…I don’t know why I did this. Vacation messes with your head, I guess.)
MODIFICATIONS: A lot!
1. The most obvious is I changed the collar. I attempted to create a series of short rows to make a “sort of” shawl collar. I don’t recommend my method at all. It looks a little…off. Not that I really remember what I did anyways. Yikes….
2. I streettccched out the underarm part to add in 6 more stitches than the X-Small called for and the sleeves are still pretty tight, but I like them that way.
3. I didn’t switch to size 6 needles like the pattern calls for. I had them with me. I don’t know why I didn’t switch. I think we were out driving and I wanted to get started on the ribbing, so just used the same needles.
BIG REGRET! The ribbing looks a little sloppy and messy, which I don’t really care for. I learned on the Simplest Sweater I just made that sloppy ribbing is not a great look. And I did it again. Hopefully I will remember next time and not do it AGAIN! Yeek!
4. I shortened it! There is a section at the end that has you “knit even in stockinette stitch for 25 rows.” I totally skipped that. Which shortened it up and I LOVE it this length! I’m short, and can’t find shorter sweaters very often, so want to make a few.
5. I shortened the sleeves. Yup. Pretty obvious… I did 3/4 sleeves again, but want to start doing longer sleeves for warmth.
What I Love About This Pattern
•It fits SOOO snugly. Love that.
•The color… I dyed it to match (but not matchy-match) these boots:
It also goes really well with the stitching in my jeans. Yay!
•The buttons… I used all different buttons as that was all I had. Weird? I think I like it! The sweater is a WEE bit tight when I do button it, but still. It works I think.
So there you have it! My completed Shapely Boyfriend Cardigan!
What’s On My Needles Now:
If you haven’t been keeping up with my next sweater progress on Facebook, here is the photo!
I’ve started the Dark and Stormy Cardigan. Several reasons I chose this…
1. I wanted to learn how to do a proper shawl collar.
2. I wanted to up my game again and this time do some cabling!
3. It’ssss awesome!!
I’m doing it in the same yarn, in my Glass Blue colorway. I’m currently waiting on another shipment of dyes and will dye up lots more of this shade once the dyes get in!
So whaddya think?
I liiivvvee for your comments, so post below and tell me your thoughts and let me know what you’re working on! I read and LOVE every comment.
Have a spectacular day!
XOXOXO
Chandi
Beautiful job on the Boyfriend Sweater! It looks wonderful on you! Can’t wait to see the completed Dark and Stormy sweater!
I’ll keep you updated!
This is a gorgeous color and the pattern has just enough cables, etc. to make it interesting and slimming. You go, Girl!
Looks good! Love your yarn. Love reading your posts. 🙂
Woo hoo! Thanks!
Chandi
Love your work, and love hearing about your progress with your projects. Oh yes and congratulations on your engagement you will be a beautiful bride.
Julie
YAYAY! Thank you!
Way to go, girl! I’m short, too : 4’11”. Even in petite sections I can’t find much that fits well. This length is very flattering! You can actually see that you have hips! (A very good thing!) Cheers!!!
Oh, yay! I’m 5’1″ and my legs always look so short. 😀 I actually try to minimize my hips as I’m “bottom heavy.” But still like some curves. ACH! It’s all such a delicate balance of proportion. 🙂
I LOVE this sweater. I wish I knew had meow experience knitting so that I could make this one too. I can’t believe how fast you knit. Love reading your blog.
SueEllen
Aw, thanks! It just takes practice I think. One stitch at a time. 😀
It is adorable! I am working on a drop stitch top, yes summery, but I now live in southern CA where the lowest temp I have experienced id 32*. I am from northern NY where the lowest temp I know I have experienced is -65*. 🙂
Oh yikes. Yep, it gets that cold here in Fairbanks, so I’m stocking up on sweaters NOW. Eeee!!!
Chandi,
The tips and comments on your projects are so helpful! Please don’t stop sharing your projects and progress with us.
I LOVE the color, and I think it is very cool that it matches the stitching on your jeans. Very subtle, yet very stylish. I cannot wait for your next update on your current project. I’m going to try the simple sweater you did in the beautiful, rich blue (sorry, I forgot the name). I’m having a very hard time deciding on what colorway I want to use for that and I just got a bunch of dyes delivered to play with 🙂
Have a great day!
<3
Oh I’m so happy you like the progress posts. 😀 I do plan on continuing to do them for you! 😀
Have fun with your dyes!
Your hair looks great! I enjoy doing cables. After I finish my X-Mas presents I think I will start this pattern.
Thank you!
I’m sure hoping you dye some more of this blueglass color – it’s one of the ones I tried to order but it sold out TOO FAST. Love the cables on this shawl collar – can’t wait to see this one as you knit.
Your “butterscotch” cardigan is so cute with the changes you made, and having a fiancé who takes such great photos of your projects really helps us, as well.
Hi Chandi!! I love the way the boyfriend sweater turned out!!! It looks great on you!! You have seriously inspired me to start knitting!! So far I’m practicing knitting and purling! It’s fun! I checked you out on you tube and started from there!! Hopefully I will get the nerve to start a sweater soon!! I love reading your blog and your comments!!I can’t wait to see the progress and the finished sweater you are currently working on!! It will be beautiful in your blue yarn!!! You go Girl!!!
Naomi
Hi, Chandra, I have had this pattern for a while and its next on my list. Hearing you talk about the size makes me know that I need to make my true size and use small needles for trim around the front and bottom. It looks great on you, but I am definitely not a small. I like the look of the other pattern that you started, Could you mention it name so that I could buy it from Revelry.
I always watch what you are knitting and enjoy your comments. Pat
Sure, Pat, my next sweater is Dark and Stormy on Ravelry.com 😀
I love the color of this sweater! As anew knitter, I want to say thank you for being honest in your posts. We all do things out of laziness that we know we shouldn’t. I appreciate you being honest about what you did and why you do or do not like it. It is helping me learn!
Have a lovely day!
Oh, you are so welcome! Glad it helps. If it prevents someone else from making that same mistake, it was worth it to post about it. 😀
Nice work Chandi and I love the color! Since I am a fall color palette it speaks to me. I have a question about the boyfriend sweater. I have this one saved on Rav to do for me but when I read your comments I am getting the feeling that the sizing for the sweater might run a bit small and wonder if I should go up in size as I don’t want a tight fitting sweater. Can’t wait to see the new sweater it inspires me to get going on my own! Thanks.
No, I just didn’t get gauge, honestly, plus I made a size which was smaller than me. So I think if you made the recommended size and did a gauge swatch, you’d be ok!
I think your sweater came out very cute. I’m very new to knitting so I’m trying to make the Gap-tastic cowl right now. I’m excited to finish it soon hopefully. I can’t wait to see how the dark and stormy sweater turns out. I love reading your posts on Facebook almost every day! 🙂
YAY! Oh, thank you so much! Good luck on the Gaptastic!
This looks terrific on you!!! Great photo shoot. Love how you admit to mistakes in your projects but to be honest; I’d not have noticed if you hadn’t mentioned it. I for one, like un-matched buttons, it adds another layer of character to the sweater. 🙂
woo hoo! Glad you like the buttons. 😀
I love this sweater on you!!! Super duper adorable!
YAY!
Hey Chandi! Just found your blog and store and love what you have to say. I was reading a little about the 20 things a few posts back, it reminds me so much of myself! Your blog is so much more down-to-earth than most of the other knitting professionals I’ve followed – I just love your style. It’s a dream of mine to be able to run my own business and be able to do what I love for a living. You’re an inspiration to me, I’m still young, so maybe hopefully in the near future!!
Oh thank you SO much!!
Beautiful! I love the choice for your next knit, too! I love Thea Coleman’s work!
Hello Chandi
I love reading your blog and following what you are making, I tried to down load the simple sweater pattern and it wouldn’t let me, don’t know what I am doing wrong but I will figure it out. I would love to knit it for myself. love how the boyfriend sweater looks on you, you are so tiny. What do you call your hair style, I would love to get my hair cut something like yours. Just wondering if there is a name for the style. the sweater you are making now is beautiful, but I am not that great at cables I find them difficult I don’t know why but I do. Any suggestions?
Please keep sharing . TerryLee Diemert
TerryLee, cables are quite simple really. Don’t feel daunted by them. Knit a small swatch with chunky (bulky) wool and practice simple cables so you get the hang of them. Then you can progress to more challenging ones. Don’t give up and read Chandi’s blog she is an inspiration!
I think it turned out beautifully!! I really like a nice fitted sweater from time to time, but that would be one teeny tiny boyfriend! Butterscotch was a great color choice for your coloring. That stormy sweater looks scary!! Good luck!!!
I think that it looks gorgeous! LOVE the different buttons!
Even being snug and having looser ribbing it works! WONDERFUL outcome! 😉
Love the boyfriend sweater, would love to make it for granddaughter. Looks beautiful on you.
Love the shape, length and fit on you; it looks fab! I’m tall at 5′ 10″ and there’s rather more of me (tho I’m losing weight, 23lb so far) and am a spring colourways girl (ha!! Rather more than a girl..). Polar opposites then, but I love your honesty and mind set. You are definitely inspiring ♡
Chandi! You are brilliant! Love reading your self deprecating blogs. Loooove the boyfriend sweater and yes you can get away with it being so fitted. Looking forward to seeing the dark n stormy sweater too – really like that colour way. How do you find the time to knit so much??!!
It looks amazing! I only just started knitting so I hope I can make a nice sweater for myself sometime in the near future!
P.S. You are stunningly gorgeous! 🙂
You have some very awesome designs and beautiful yarn 🙂 I’m not usually one to believe in being “inspired,” but I actually came across your website through your knitting tutorials on youtube. I put knitting down about two years ago and haven’t picked it back up because I got so frustrated trying to learn. I’m a crocheter and I love yarn, so I picked it up and tried again with your videos I found – and for once I though, hey, I can do this! I appreciate that you relate the knitting tips to crocheting – that really helped – and the tip about how to pick up a dropped stitch with a crochet hook – brilliant! Like I said, I usually one to see “inspirational” things as cheesy or hokey, to put it bluntly as bs. But I really am impressed with your story about how you started your business, and it gives me hope for my own little hobby shop 🙂 So may I congratulate you on boosting this little cynic’s confidence in inspiration 🙂 And thanks so much for the knitting lessons!
Greetings from Singapore.
Lovely knit with great colour.
Warmly.